top of page
  • Writer's pictureNICE

When Dog Training May Not Be the Best Solution: A Comprehensive Guide

Training is one part of dog guardianship, helping to shape behaviours, strengthen the bond between you and your dog and ensure their wellbeing. However, there are certain circumstances when dog training might not be the most appropriate or beneficial route to take. Here are some of these scenarios:

Health Issues

One scenario that demands careful consideration before initiating training is when your pet is dealing with health issues. These can range from acute illnesses such as infections or injuries, to chronic conditions like arthritis or heart disease.

In these cases, your dog's health and comfort should unequivocally be the top priority. Even seemingly benign training exercises can be strenuous, both physically and mentally, for a dog in ill health. Training requires focus, energy, and often physical exertion, all of which can take a toll on a dog who is already not feeling well.

Additionally, the stress associated with training can potentially exacerbate health problems. For example, a dog with heart disease may experience increased heart rate and blood pressure during training, which could worsen their condition. Similarly, a dog with a physical injury could further injure themselves if asked to perform physical tasks during training.

Moreover, the discomfort or pain associated with the health issue may also delay the recovery process. A dog needs rest to recuperate, and pushing them to train could lead to overexertion, consequently slowing down the healing process.

It's also essential to remember that a dog feeling unwell might behave differently, not because they're being 'stubborn' or 'difficult', but as a reaction to their discomfort. In these instances, training can not only be ineffective but also potentially distressing for the dog.

Therefore, before embarking on any new training endeavour, it is of the utmost importance to consult with your veterinarian. They can assess your pet's condition, consider the demands of the intended training, and give the necessary advice on whether it's safe and suitable to proceed. This precautionary step will ensure your beloved dog's wellbeing is always kept at the forefront.

Previous Trauma

If a dog has experienced previous trauma, whether through abuse, neglect, or even previous poorly executed training methods, diving straight into traditional training can be challenging and may not always yield positive results. In fact, it could potentially do more harm than good.

Trauma can leave deep emotional scars on dogs, just as it does with humans. The memories of their past experiences can lead to behavioural issues like fear, aggression, anxiety, and difficulty in forming bonds. Traditional training methods, particularly those that use negative reinforcement or punishment, can trigger these traumatic memories, resulting in heightened anxiety or defensive behaviour.

In addition, dogs that have been subjected to poor training methods in the past may associate training with fear, discomfort, or confusion. This could lead to a lack of trust in the process, and a subsequent reluctance or resistance to training in general.

In these cases, a different approach is needed — one that focuses on rebuilding trust and confidence. This approach requires a slower pace, immense patience, and a deeper understanding of the dog's emotional state. It's about creating a safe space where the dog feels comfortable and gradually introducing elements of training in a non-threatening manner.

The emphasis should be on positive reinforcement, rewarding even small progress, and continuously validating the dog's efforts.

Moreover, consider reaching out to professionals who specialise in dealing with dogs with traumatic backgrounds. These experts are trained to recognise the signs of trauma, understand its effects, and implement effective, trauma-sensitive training strategies. They can provide tailored advice and techniques to help your dog overcome past experiences and learn in a more positive and supportive environment.

Ultimately, the goal is to transform training from a potentially frightening experience into an opportunity for your dog to gain confidence, build a strong bond with you, and live a happier, healthier life. This journey may be challenging, but with patience, understanding, and professional guidance, it can be incredibly rewarding.

Needs and Environmental Concerns

Before starting any training programme, it's essential to ensure your dog's basic needs are being met. This includes proper nutrition, regular exercise, socialisation, and mental stimulation. If these fundamental needs aren't satisfied, the dog might display undesirable behaviours not because of a lack of training, but as a way of communicating unmet needs or distress.

The environment in which a dog lives plays a significant role in shaping their behaviour and receptiveness to training. Factors such as constant noise, lack of space, overcrowding with people or other animals, lack of routine, and crucially, a lack of safety, can all contribute to a stressful living situation for the dog.

Imagine trying to learn something new in a chaotic, noisy environment where you didn't feel safe or secure — it would be extremely challenging, wouldn't it? The same holds true for dogs.

Constant noise, for instance, can keep a dog in a state of heightened alertness, disrupting their ability to concentrate on training. Similarly, limited space or overcrowded living conditions can lead to increased tension and competition for resources, causing anxiety and potential behavioural problems.

A lack of routine can create uncertainty, as dogs thrive on consistency. Regular feeding times, walks, and periods of rest help to give structure to a dog's day. When this routine is inconsistent or non-existent, it can cause stress and confusion, negatively affecting a dog's ability to focus and learn.

Arguably the most important factor, however, is safety. Dogs, like all animals, need to feel safe in their environment. If they are living in conditions where they feel threatened or unsafe, be it due to aggressive animals, abusive people, or insecure surroundings, their primary focus will be on self-preservation rather than learning new behaviours.

In such situations, addressing the environmental concerns should come before training. This might involve reducing noise levels, ensuring the dog has a space of their own, establishing a consistent routine, and most importantly, creating a safe and secure environment.

Only once these issues have been resolved can a dog truly benefit from training. A calm, safe, and predictable living environment sets the foundation for effective learning and helps to ensure that training is a positive and productive experience for your dog.


Pain can significantly impact a dog's behaviour and their ability to engage in training. Just like humans, dogs will instinctively try to avoid situations that cause or exacerbate their pain. Depending on the severity and source of the pain, a dog might display aggression, fear, anxiety, or other changes in behaviour, making training not only ineffective but potentially harmful.

It's vital to remember that changes in behaviour are often a way for dogs to communicate that something is amiss. Aggression, for instance, could be a defensive response to protect a painful area from being touched. Fear or anxiety might stem from associating certain activities with the pain they cause. Inability to concentrate during training could be due to the constant distraction of discomfort.

Some signs of pain in dogs can include limping, decreased appetite, excessive grooming or licking of a specific area, restlessness, reluctance to move or jump, and changes in behaviour like aggression or withdrawal. Noticing these signs is the first step in identifying a potential problem.

There are various reasons why a dog might be in pain. They could have sustained an injury, be suffering from an illness, or have a chronic condition like arthritis or hip dysplasia. Dental issues can also cause considerable discomfort. Furthermore, as dogs age, they become more susceptible to various health conditions that can lead to pain.

Before proceeding with any behavioural training, it's crucial to address the underlying issue causing the pain. Consulting with a veterinarian is essential to diagnose the source of the pain accurately and to provide appropriate treatment. This might involve medication, surgery, physical therapy, or adjustments to the dog's lifestyle and diet.

Once the source of the pain has been addressed and the dog is on the path to recovery, then you can consider resuming or initiating training, always taking into account your pet's health and comfort. Keep in mind that training should always be a positive experience, never a source of discomfort or distress.

In conclusion, while training is an essential part of dog ownership, there are situations where it might not be the right choice. Always consider the individual circumstances of your dog, prioritise their health and wellbeing, and don't hesitate to seek professional help when necessary. We all share the same goal — to provide the best care for our furry companions.

Calling All Dog Professionals

If you're a professional in the canine industry, we invite you to join us in our mission. Your expertise and experience are invaluable in shaping the future of dog welfare. As a professional member of the National Institute for Canine Ethics, you'll have access to a range of benefits including educational resources, networking opportunities, and the chance to contribute to our work in a meaningful way.

Let us together pave the path towards a world where every decision made about a dog's life is an ethical one, where every choice enhances their welfare. It's more than just an opportunity; it's a calling. Join us, and let's make a difference for man's best friend, one ethical choice at a time.

891 views0 comments


bottom of page